In light of and and so on I'm also very tempted to block the instance. And this makes me somewhat sad because I think I would have wanted to like the idea.

· Web · 3 · 0 · 1

It seems Purism is planning on reverting this decision/code, see As I haven't seen nor had reports of problematic behaviour from the instance I will not block it but will revisit this decision regularly (every week?) until there's either no reason anymore because they accept reports again, or because I got tired of waiting and no progress was visible. /cc @Drezil @uniporn

Zeige Konversation

It seems this did never materialize, they even seem to have dug in their heels that’s it for federating with that instance then /cc @Drezil @uniporn

Zeige Konversation


@thegcat I'm tempted to just write "Do it!", but I gues that' some portion of defiance in me calling for this. Hence I have to admit I see out point in linking the idea, however when trying to expand a community they should try to expand it, not to accept decay of culture for sake of monitisation or intend to change in the first place - one rule about relationships I have been taught is not to hope for the change of the other half - it's dishonest and doesn't even work. jm2c...

@thegcat I would block them instantly as long as they don't offer a report function for users.

It would be interesting how the new regulations in Germany (NetzDG etc.) would be applied to such a social network .. as they take money & are way beyond "hobby" they should have to handle it with all the might of the law..

btw: are you liable (via NetzDG) for federating with them when you cannot block/report them? Or is there another way?

@Drezil I can still block the instance, so I'd guess that in case of problematic contents I could still block either single users of the instance or the whole instance and remove the problematic content from this instance. I think that would be enough comply with current regulations. Not sure about upcoming regulations.

@Drezil The whole "operators need to scan user data" makes any federated-type service exponentially difficult to host though, as you can't guarantee whomever operates other federated entities has performed the appropriate checks and you'd need to scan however big a chunk of the federated space you're engaged with on your own instance. Let's say this doesn't scale very well.

@thegcat Well .. when i report things they will get reported to you first & i can select to forward the report to the other instance as well..
NetzDG is only reactive, not pre-active .. you have 24hrs after a user-complaint.. if you have a significant amount of users .. but IANAL..

@Drezil yes, that part of the answer was more geared towards upcoming european legislation, for which I'm not sure if and what steps we will be required to take.

Melde dich an, um an der Konversation teilzuhaben

Mastodon ist ein soziales Netzwerk. Es basiert auf offenen Web-Protokollen und freier, quelloffener Software. Es ist dezentral (so wie E-Mail!).